Thoughts and traits are molded and changed due to one’s past. In fact, the ongoing debate of nature vs. nurture or “the extent to which particular aspects of behavior are a product of either inherited (i.e. genetic) or acquired (i.e. learned) characteristics” has strong evidence for how one’s environment impacts their life (SimplyPsychology). Expanding on the idea that people are influenced by their environment, cities and communities take an important role in shaping the people that live in them. In Robin Kelley’s biography of Thelonious Monk and the film, Leimert Park, both agree on the fact that community and jazz are intertwined.
Thelonious Monk is a great example of how a community forged a jazz genius. Monk moved to New York from North Carolina with his mother Barbara, sister Marion, and brother Thomas. After jumping around for a bit they ended up landing in the infamous San Juan Hill Neighborhood. San Juan Hill boasted a community of extremely talented musicians that inspired Monk to try new techniques and styles. In the biography of Thelonious Monk, Kelley explains that “Thelonious learned from the many Jazz musicians that lived in the neighborhood” including but not limited to “saxophonist Benny Carter (who moved to Harlem after leaving his parents’ house), his neighbors included the pianist Freddy Johnson (who would later work with Benny Carter and Coleman Hawkins), [and] reed player Russell Procope (who played with Benny Carter, Chick Webb, and eventually Duke Ellington)” (81). Thelonious was surrounded and taught by professionals which influenced his style of playing and brought him to a higher level at a young age. His playing in the community church and community center also improved his abilities. His mother Barbara would teach Thelonious some hymns and he “would accompany her when she sang at Reverend W.A. Johnson’s Church on West 61st street” (83). The church built up Monk’s confidence and influenced his playing by allowing him to embed his love for piano even more in the community. Also in Kelley’s words, other than Monk’s mother, “the most important influence on Monk’s early development wasn’t a person-but an institution--The Columbus Hill Neighborhood Center” (84). The community center offered Monk a place to socialize with his friends and enjoy recreation and games. However the center also held a “music contest for a scholarship to the Juilliard School of Music” (88). The community also boasted other similar age musical virtuosos such as “Louis Taylor, a thirteen year old piano prodigy who lived a couple doors down from the Monks” (88). There was a constant competition from Monks peers which gave him a solid work ethic in which to try harder and push himself to become the best.
San Juan Hill created a jazz genius, Leimert Park’s was different in that its sense of community was created by jazz. Before jazz in Leimert park there was no downtown life or sense of community. Most people moved into Leimert park for its African Culture but were somewhat disarray when it came to being united. However the introduction of the Coffee House and places like the World Stage started a wheel that is still turning today. Music and African culture became a stronghold in Leimert park thanks to the jazz clubs which sparked a regular community to unite and socialize.
Work Cited
Simply Psychology. http://www.simplypsychology.org/naturevsnurture.html
Kelley, Robin D.G. Thelonious Monk: the Life and Times of an American Original
I definitely agree with your stance on San Juan Hill's role in the formation of Thelonious Monk's musical genius. The 'nature vs. nurture' argument that you put forth was a unique one and very interesting to read. What a "genius" way to incorporate environmental thinking into your blog.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that Jazz played a role in creating a sense of community in Leimert Park. Why do you think that was able to happen in Leimert Park and not in other neighborhoods (like San Juan Hill)? Great explanation of Monk's upbringing as affecting his musical style.
ReplyDelete